Boundary Monism
Paper

The Shape of a Total Theory: A Necessary-Conditions Net

The paper derives the questions any total theory has to take a position on, before looking at any candidate theory.

Every total theory has to be

consistentIts commitments hold together, with the road from self-reference to paradox closed. C1, consistency
well-definedIts state space, law and measures are shown to exist. C2, well-definedness
honest about its baseWhatever it uses and cannot derive is declared. C3, primitive honesty
self-includingIt places the people who hold it inside the world it describes. C4, reflexive closure
groundedIts chain of explanation closes, with no open regress and no hidden circle. C5, explanatory groundedness
uniformIts principles apply to every case, with no special pleading. C6, rule uniformity
anchored to the worldIts terms are tied to reality by more than a count or an arbitrary reading. C7, content anchoring

and take a position on

arenaWhat kind of thing is fundamental.
spacetimeWhat our world puts here: spacetime.
cosmic historyWhat our world puts here: cosmic history.
modalityThe space of possibilities, and what marks the actual.
matterWhat the theorist is made of and how it interacts.
particles and forcesWhat our world puts here: particles and forces.
gravityWhat our world puts here: gravity.
dynamicsThe ordering along which the theorist persists and changes.
the specific lawWhat our world puts here: the specific law.
records and time's arrowThe stable, past-directed traces that knowledge requires.
the arrow's sourceWhat our world puts here: the arrow's source.
definitenessHow determinate facts arise.
interiorityWhether, and why, some processes have an inside.
agencyThe intervention and selection by which theories are tested.

Loading the paper…

Applied to Boundary Monism

Boundary Monism grew out of working through the net, and the net shows where it is strong and where it owes work. Its firmest answer is to primitive honesty (C3): the base holds no stock of individuated objects, and things are derived from the dynamics by one test. Its central structure answers reflexive closure (C4): the rule that selects things is a fixed point, and the theorist is selected by it with no exemption. On content anchoring (C7) the dynamics supplies the privileged relations that bare structural realism lacks: a reinterpretation that keeps the theory’s shape loses the law’s action, so it cannot change which patterns are things or what records are about, which answers Newman’s and Putnam’s objections on the theory’s founding posit that the dynamics is what there is.

Two debts remain. Which division of the world into parts the law picks is open for degenerate laws, the nearest thing the theory has to a smuggled primitive (C3). And the fixed point is not shown to have a solution, or only one, at a given scale (C2); the unity of an experience rests on that uniqueness.